On non-Israeli privilege

A University of Toronto student named Jennifer Peto recently achieved fame by submitting a thesis called:

“The victimhood of the powerful: White Jews, Zionism, and the Racism of Hegemonic Holocaust Education”

While only in academia could one maintain respectability after making the insidious argument that those who support Holocaust Education are guilty of racism, Peto’s broader narrative, that Jews have become a “privileged” class, (in some form or another) may be more widely accepted than you might originally think, needs to be taken seriously, and aggressively refuted. 

The idea that Jews, who (65 years after the Holocaust) now represent a meager 2/10 of 1% of the world’s population, and have but one state to call their own, are now seen as “the powerful” in the diaspora, and the proverbial “Goliath” as a nation-state, is a narrative which shows the profound moral pathos which informs much of the anti-Zionist discourse coming from the activist left.

In this distortion the mere fact that Jews are relatively successful and more capable of defending (or at least advocating for) their own interests, both in the diaspora and in Israel, is, in itself, evidence that they’ve lost the mantle of victim and now represent something closer to an oppressor.

Of course, far from being an oppressor, Israel (as this blog continuously documents) has become merely the Jew writ large. That is, the same historical D’s – double standards, demonization, and delegitimization – employed against Jews throughout centuries of anti-Semitic oppression have now, in large measure, been transferred to the Jewish state, as she represents in the minds of many the Jewish collective.

Far from being privileged, Israel is held to standards that no other nation is held to – the definition of bigotry in its broadly understood term – and asked to live up to ideals that no nation in the world could uphold.

Not only aren’t Israelis privileged but something approaching the opposite is closer to the truth.

Here are the advantages (privileges) of waking up in the morning as a citizen of a nation other than Israel – the daily effects of non-Israeli privilege:

1.  You can be sure that your country’s very right to exist won’t be questioned.

2.  You don’t have your national aspirations characterized as inherently racist.

3.  You can be sure that anger over your country’s actions won’t result in violent attacks against citizens (throughout the the world) who happen to share the majority ethnicity in your state.

4.  Your nation’s democratically elected leaders won’t face arrest warrants when entering other countries.

5.  Terrorist attacks against innocent civilians in your country won’t be described as mere “resistance”, or otherwise excused, by commentators in the mainstream media.

6.  The United Nations won’t pass an egregiously disproportionate ratio of resolutions against your country condemning you for human rights abuses while ignoring far worse abuses by nations in the rest of the world.

7. Your nation won’t be subject to international calls for boycotts, sanctions, and divestment.

8.  You can be sure that even when others criticize your country it won’t be compared to Nazi Germany.

9.  When enemies committed to your state’s destruction fire missiles into your civilian territory, you can be positive the international community won’t condemn your nation for retaliating.

10.  Your national passport won’t make you persona non grata in neighboring countries.

I’m sure I missed a few, so please feel free to comment on other ways non-Israelis are privileged.

21 replies »

  1. Well, Adam, you clearly learned something about the dynamics of privilege in the ADL training! BTW: there are elements on the “hard right” who make similar non-sensical claims. Perhaps we need better “direction” descriptors; the way delegates sat at the French National Assembly is so 18th century!

  2. Hey Jerry. I agree labels such as left and right are at the least “problematic”, and I try to use terms such as “hard left” or “Guardian left” to make the distinction between the left as such, and those who have distorted the values of an otherwise noble political tradition. However, we’ll have to agree to disagree on this one, as I feel strongly that, while there are of course those on the right who hate Israel and Jews, the majority of delegitimization and demonization these days come from the “hard” left. As always, nice to hear from you…appreciate your comments.

  3. One other privilige is the ability to be able to rent houses or flats in your local currency and some currency from across the Atlatic…

  4. This woman’s got a serious number of issues, she talks about herself in the thesis: “I was an outcast in the Jewish community, and estranged from my family for being atheist, queer, gender-queer, feminist and generally outspoken in a highly normative, Orthodox setting.”

    We’re talking a rebel (now) with a cause.

  5. As a citizen of another country other than Israel, you can be assured the majority ethnicity in your country won’t be criticized for building homes (or additions to those homes) in your nation’s capital.

  6. The uk has been hijacked just as Lebanon has been hijacked.

    The swine who proclaim they are all hezbullah, whilst in the uk, are driving the uk to destruction.

  7. To these people it’s not that a Jew has too “much”, it’s that anything a Jew has is too much.

    Many thesis(plural) are exercises in futility. My personal favorite (when I worked in an Agriculture Library at a Big Ten University) was a Study in aerosol ketchup(food technology)…..this womans thesis is about as worthwhile.

  8. A very strong article. But what are we talking about when we talk of ‘standards’? The Goldstone Report; named after an ‘anti’-Apartheid judge who sentenced black people to death by hanging? Or human rights organisations receiving Palestinian aid who pointed out which ‘cases’ the Goldstone Commission should ‘investigate’?

    Or maybe we’re talking about the ‘standards’ set by ex-president Carter in his book ‘Palestine: Peace Not Apartheid’ which everyone involved in the peace processes decried it, including Bill Clinton, who said it was unfair and inaccurate?

    When you have fabrications in order to prove a ‘thesis’ it’s not any standard, it’s naked propaganda. When directed at a ‘priveleged’ people – a certain race – it doesn’t require a genius to figure that it’s just plain racism.

    When you then have such conspiracy theories raised to the level of a religion where no amount of reason or evidence persuades the faithful, you have quite a recognised and established phenomena from history.

  9. Jenny Peto. It’s all about the movement and people she loves and give each other support. There’s no awareness of the fact that she is attempting to destroy a just humane society. She is queer in that she is odd and needy.

    She isn’t aware of the reality of Israel at all. She needs to meet Douglas Murray who said that “If queers for Palestine were in Palestine they would have to go to Israel.”

  10. I’ve always disliked the use of the term “queer” for homosexuals. In Peto’s case, it seems appropriate, without any regard to her sexual preferences.

    I had the strange feeling of watching a lesbian Goebbels watching her talk.

  11. […] .tweetandlike,a.tweetandlike{float:left;display:block}.tweetandlike-container{width:100%;padding:0 0 5%}.tweetandlike-box{background:none repeat scroll 0 0 #E8F0F9;border:1px solid #ABD2E9;margin:15px 0;padding:10px}.tweetandlike-box h4{color:#3A5796;font-family:'Helvetica Neue',Arial,sans-serif;font-size:16px !important;font-weight:bold;margin-bottom:5px}.tweetandlike-container .twitter-box,.addthis-box{margin-right:10px}.box-vertical{height:90px}h4 #tweetandlike-heading{font-family:'Helvetica Neue',Arial,sans-serif;font-size:16px !important;font-weight:bold;margin-bottom:5px} /**/.wp-polls .pollbar{margin:1px;font-size:8px;line-height:10px;height:10px;background-image:url('http://www.israellycool.com/wordpress/wp-content/plugins/wp-polls/images/default_gradient/pollbg.gif&#039 ;);border:1px solid #036} var _gaq=_gaq||[];_gaq.push(['_setAccount','UA-1663636-1']);_gaq.push(['_trackPageview']);(function(){var ga=document.createElement('script');ga.type='text/javascript';ga.async=true;ga.src=('https:'==document.location.protocol?'https://ssl':'http://www')+'.google-analytics.com/ga.js';var s=document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0];s.parentNode.insertBefore(ga,s);})(); HomeAboutContactForumLegalPro-Israel Blog-Off 2011Competition RulesMeet the JudgesSupport IsraellycoolDonateIsraellycool StoreAmazon Store IsraellycoolDown Under Punditry in the Middle EastBlog AnnouncementsBlogger ArchivesCartoonsFeaturedGeneralJIB AwardsJIB Awards 2004JIB Awards 2005MT ArchivesMy Charmed LifePodcastsSeparated at Birthgoogle_ad_client="pub-1814888804267607";google_ad_slot="4527701887";google_ad_width=120;google_ad_height=600; /**/ Powered by WebAdsRecent CommentsWhat Others Say "He single-handedly does the best job of knocking down Israel haters online that I've ever seen" – Israelplug "The father of Israeli blogging" – Carl in Jerusalem "..expertly analyzes international media reactions to the news in Israel" – Maya Norton, Global Voices "Snarky humor, funny photo comparisons, and frustrations with the geopolitical neighborhood all clash for a lovely symphony of madness." – Laurence Simon "..wise and passionate.." – Political Vindication Radio "He can turn a very serious and possibly depressing piece of news and make it entertainment. That is talent, and that is why I love to read his blog." – Culture For All "..the notorious Israellycool.com, which gently skips between right-wing rants against Islam, posts about science fiction and – what else? – blogs about the Eurovision song contest." – Tim Jonze, The Guardian "..the liar & moral pygmy who writes Israellycool & makes feeble attempts to ridicule my views" – Dick Silverstein CategoriesBlog Announcements (204)Blogger Archives (369)Cartoons (10)Featured (71)General (4870)JIB Awards (76)JIB Awards 2004 (29)JIB Awards 2005 (36)MT Archives (827)My Charmed Life (98)Podcasts (74)Separated at Birth (319) May 2011MTWTFSS« Apr   12345678910111213141516171819202122232425262728293031 ArchivesMay 2011April 2011March 2011February 2011January 2011December 2010November 2010October 2010September 2010August 2010July 2010June 2010May 2010April 2010March 2010February 2010January 2010December 2009November 2009October 2009September 2009August 2009July 2009June 2009May 2009April 2009March 2009February 2009January 2009December 2008November 2008October 2008September 2008August 2008July 2008June 2008May 2008April 2008March 2008February 2008January 2008December 2007November 2007October 2007September 2007August 2007July 2007June 2007May 2007April 2007March 2007February 2007January 2007December 2006November 2006October 2006September 2006August 2006July 2006June 2006May 2006April 2006March 2006February 2006January 2006December 2005November 2005October 2005September 2005August 2005July 2005June 2005May 2005April 2005March 2005February 2005January 2005December 2004November 2004October 2004September 2004August 2004July 2004June 2004May 2004April 2004March 2004February 2004January 2004December 2003November 2003October 2003September 2003August 2003July 2003June 2003April 2003March 2003February 2000January 2000 google_ad_client="pub-1814888804267607";google_ad_slot="7140790221";google_ad_width=468;google_ad_height=60; Pro-Israel Blog-Off: First Semi Final May 16, 2011 | Aussie Dave | Comments 277720http%3A%2F%2Fwww.israellycool.com%2F2011%2F05%2F16%2Fpro-israel-blog-off-first-semi-final%2FPro-Israel+Blog-Off%3A+First+Semi+Final2011-05-16+05%3A50%3A54Aussie+Davehttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.israellycool.com%2F%3Fp%3D27772/**/ Here are the submissions for the first Semi Final of the 2011 Pro-Israel Blog-Off.Please click on each of the links to view them, and then vote for your favorite one in the poll.You may only vote once (I will be monitoring the voting logs, so any irregularities will be dealt with).Voting closes Sunday May 22nd 11:59PM Israel time.The final results (based on the reader votes and judges’ score) will be posted early next week.Good luck!Elder of Ziyon: This is ZionismCIF Watch: On Non-Israeli Privilege———————————————————————————————-Which Is The Best Pro-Israel Post? This is Zionism On Non-Israeli PrivilegeView Results Loading … ShareTweet google_ad_client="pub-1814888804267607";google_ad_slot="7745386758";google_ad_width=336;google_ad_height=280; Filed Under: General Tags: Pro-Israel Blog-Off About the Author: An Australian immigrant to Israel, Aussie Dave has been blogging since early 2003.Comments (277720http%3A%2F%2Fwww.israellycool.com%2F2011%2F05%2F16%2Fpro-israel-blog-off-first-semi-final%2FPro-Israel+Blog-Off%3A+First+Semi+Final2011-05-16+05%3A50%3A54Aussie+Davehttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.israellycool.com%2F%3Fp%3D27772)Trackback URLLeave a Reply Click here to cancel reply. Name (required) Mail (will not be published) (required) WebsiteIf you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a Gravatar. […]

  12. Another addition to the list that dovetails with CornedBeefPiledHigh’s is that other countries will recognize the city that you choose as your capital, as such, and place their embassies there.

  13. I used to be recommended this blog by means of my cousin. I am not positive whether or not this submit is written by him as nobody else understand such specified about my trouble. You’re amazing! Thanks!

  14. I just got back from Israel…my cousins live there . I do not think any american or canadian jew can accurately comment on such matters until they lived there for a while.. I hung out with mitzrahi (jews from arab countries that were expelled in 1948 which make up 60% of populas) Ethiopian jews (not from sweden like Moses…lol) Lemba africans and Druize( moslems who fight for Israel). I thought how strange and twisted the world media is claiming Israel is racist? All of us including christians moslems black white arab all lived worked and prayed together protected by the IDF. Sadly we were not safe east Jerusalem PLO would beat up or even murder us in “their” village but they were allowed to walk around freely by us??? Why is it that Israel allows all other religions in Jerusalem even though it is against TORAH law? Yet we cannot safely visit Mecca or Medina let alone build a synagogue there… I have never realized how slanted world media is against us. Reform Judaism is ng. james ainoris