Guardian

Fatah arrests 8 Hamas members. Israel arrests 1. Which do you think Harriet Sherwood reported?


On Jan. 9, the Palestinian Times reported that Fatah arrested 8 Hamas members, including a journalist, in the West Bank over several days.  The report also alleged that Fatah arbitrarily extended the detention of other Hamas members, and of firing a teacher who is a member of the group.

Fatah arresting Hamas members in the West Bank

On Jan. 19th, Israel arrested one Hamas member Aziz Dweik , on suspicion of involvement with terrorist activity.

On Jan. 20th, Harriet Sherwood rushed to advocate on behalf of the Hamas terrorist arrested by Israel, posting a piece titled “Israeli jails Palestinian parliament speaker without trial“.  However, further in the article, even Sherwood acknowledges that Dweik is a Parliament speaker in name only, as the Palestinian Legislative Council has not sat since the summer of 2007, when Hamas – which had won elections the previous year – took control of Gaza in a bloody battle with Fatah.

The Guardian also posted a video on Jan. 20 championing the cause of the Hamas speaker of the non-existent Parliament.

Yet, strangely absent from the Guardian’s Israel, Palestinian Territories, or Gaza pages are any mention whatsoever of Fatah’s arrest of eight Hamas members.  Nor mentioned, in service of providing background to Sherwood’s story, was the fact that in 2008 PA security forces aligned with Abbas arrested hundreds of Hamas members and supporters and, further, in 2009, nearly all Hamas-controlled municipal officials were replaced by Fatah officials.

Context similarly missing from Sherwood’s report is the fact that Hamas arrested thousands of Fatah loyalists in Gaza  in 2010 alone, including PA legislators. And, a report in the Palestinian Press as recently as Dec. 30, 2o11 noted that such arrests of Fatah members continued through 2011.

Sherwood characterized the arrest of Dweik as an effort by Israel “to undermine democratic institutions in Palestine”, and hinder reconciliation between the two groups.

Yet, the Palestinians, by any measure, have failed miserably on their own at establishing anything resembling genuinely democratic institutions, as President Mahmoud Abbas is currently serving the seventh year of a four year term, and, per Freedom House, the PA is listed as not free“.

“In the Palestinian Authority administered territories, political rights rating declined from 5 to 6 [7 is the worst score] due to the expiration of President Mahmoud Abbas four-year term in January 2009, the ongoing lack of a functioning elected legislature, and an edict allowing the removal of elected municipal governments in the West Bank.”

So, while the arrest of one Hamas member by Israel elicits a storm of criticism by the Guardian, scores of arrests by Fatah of Hamas officials, and Hamas members by Fatah officials, is evidently considered insignificant to contextualizing the lack of a functioning democracy in the Palestinian controlled territories.

More broadly, both this latest report, and Sherwood’s continuing reports from the region, seem to possess a unique capacity to blame Israel in some manner for every conceivable Palestinian failure, while similarly denying Palestinians basic moral agency (the definition of liberal racism) – a journalistic dynamic which prevents honest reporting on the I-P Conflict.  

8 replies »

  1. Sherwood:
    “The recent arrests are seen as part of an Israeli crackdown on the movement and activity of senior Palestinian figures, which is thought to be connected to moves towards reconciliation between Fatah and Hamas. Israel strongly opposes Palestinian reconciliation, believing it will give Hamas greater influence.”

    The impression she gives is that Fatah and Hamas have been the verge of reconciliation – which is somewhat compromised by the story of Fatah arrestsing eight Hamas men just two weeks beforehand.

    • Thank you for stating the obvious, pretzel.

      (“I love pretzels (Oh, well, I guess I’ll eat some chips.”)

  2. I don’t know if it’s my imagination but there seems to be a greater than usual onslaught against Israel in the Guardian in the last week or two. This report of La Sherwood is part of it, together with several articles plus a video about Palestinian children arrested by Israel, (which you wrote about herenot to mention several inflammatory letters on the subject. This is all besides the usual stuff in CiF.

    Am I imagining it or have I simply not been paying enough attention?

  3. No, you are not. This has been going on for some time. Add Borger on Iran,Greenslade and others on media and culture. Generally in areas where no comments are allowed to undermine the falsehoods.

    Borger was particularly nauseating today, trying to whip up the faithful by rehashing an NYT article by an Israeli who claims that Israel will attack Iran. They made the mistake of allowing comments, however.

    http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/julian-borger-global-security-blog/2012/jan/25/israel-iran

    The letters look suspiciously coordinated, and, of course, there are none supporting Israel against the issue of jailing “children” for throwing stones or shooting at Israelis.

  4. Sherwood is read by millions of readers, including the Governement of Britain. Levick is read by… well… a few dozens of CIF Watch readers and his family. Tells it all…

    • CiFWatch is also ready by the Guardian who have amended their articles several times in response to articles here. So you can take your inane gloating and stuff it where the sun don’t shine.