Times of London

Times of London falsely claims Israel ‘formally annexed’ land in the West Bank


The Times of London, on Sept. 2, published an article by Gregg Carlstrom about a recent decision by Israeli authorities to declare 988 acres in the Gush Etzion region of Judea and Samaria (close to where three Israeli teens were kidnapped and murdered in June) ‘state land’ (Israel makes biggest land grab in 30 years after teens murdered). 

Here’s a map of the area in question:

map

Map created by Ha’aretz

The Times of London article (behind a pay wall) included this opening passage:

orig

However, it is completely inaccurate to say that Israel “formally annexed” the land in question, as such formal annexation would require legislation and approval in the Knesset, a formal process that only occurred in two cases – east Jerusalem and the Golan Heights.  

The term “annexation” implies sovereignty, and any area that was “formally annexed” would mean the application of Israeli law to that territory. This is not the case when Israel merely declares an area to be “state land”, which does not imply sovereignty.

Even Peace Now (the group referred to in the Times of London article) doesn’t claim that the land in question was “formally annexed”, only that it was “declared state land”.

Additionally, none of the other UK papers reporting on the story that we reviewed (including the Guardian, Telegraph, Financial Times, Daily Mail and Independent) included the word “annexed” in their accounts.

After contacting editors at Times of London, they slightly revised the sentence in question, deleting the word “formally”.

revised
However, the change is completely insufficient, as the passage’s inclusion of the word “annexation” is extremely misleading.

8 replies »

  1. The incredible shrinking “land grab” stared at 1,000 acres, became 990, now is 988 … and the map above doesn’t show the reality, which is that this “massive land grab” is incredibly tiny – about 1.5 sq miles, or about the size of Central Park spread out as a ribbon of land mostly less than 1/2 a km wide running along the Green Line with a piece connecting to Gush Etzion of about the same dimensions..

  2. Of course they ignore the fact that all the land does belong to Israel legally and that the Arabs have not one single legal claim.

  3. Hi, Neat post. There’s an issue together with your website in internet
    explorer, could check this? IE still is the markket chief
    and a large section of folks will omit your great writing because of this problem.

  4. It was not introduced as an accounting discipline but as part
    of mathematical procedures, which merchants could utilize in monitoring their assets, liabilities and investment exposure (capital).

    Bookkeeping is a name given to the process that is undertaken to maintain records of the business transactions done on a daily
    basis. Additionally, you will receive monthly client ledger trial balances from the bank, which you can then match
    with your office client ledger records. Having retained a separate receipt for
    everything it is useful if the receipts are filed
    and the bookkeeping system employed updated at least once a month and preferably each week.

  5. Modern day London is a huge metropolis with everything on offer from history to cutting
    edge modernity as well as a vast selection of places to stay including the numerous grand plaza apartments London offers.
    Many people think that serviced apartments only cater to these
    two niche markets. They are not meant to offer honest advice and are just sales tools.
    Paris Serviced apartments are self-catering where you can do and manage things on your own.