Independent

Contrary to UK media claims, there are NO Israeli restrictions on stethoscopes entering Gaza


A recent report in The Independent on a Canadian doctor of Palestinian descent who is developing a new easy-to-manufacture inexpensive stethoscope for Gaza hospitals contextualizes the story thusly:

stethosopes

The first few passages set up the story:

A doctor in the Gaza Strip who was faced with the fallout of an eight-year blockade in the territory has taken matters into his own hands and created a low-cost stethoscope with a 3D printer.

The crossings between Gaza and the borders of Israel and Egypt were blocked eight years ago, after Hamas seized power in the region.The blockade has been blamed for damaging Gaza’s economy, casting its 1.8 million citizens into poverty, and creating a shortage of vital supplies.

Additionally, a Sept. 11th article in The Metro similarly claimed that Israel’s blockade has resulted in shortages of stethoscopes.

metro article 

However, as Elder of Ziyon noted recently, there’s a major inconsistency with such stories: There are NO Israeli restrictions on stethoscopes (or other medical supplies) entering Gaza.  

The only restricted items are weapons and ‘dual-use’ items, those putatively civilian items which can be used “for the development, production, installation or enhancement of military capabilities and terrorist capacities”.   Indeed, purely humanitarian supplies (such as medical supplies and medicines) have never been subject to such restrictions, even during wartime.

Moreover, as Hadar Sela (managing editor of our sister site, BBC Watch) demonstrated last month in a post refuting an August BBC World Service radio program (available here from 38:32) which noted the 3D printed stethoscopes by Dr. Loubani, shortages of medical equipment in Gaza are primarily due “to long-standing disputes between the Palestinian Authority and Hamas“.

But, of course, if we’ve learned anything about UK media’s insistence on maintaining the desired narrative about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, carefully examining the specific causes of suffering and deprivation in Gaza – thus challenging their readers’ stereotypes and preconceived notions – is simply not part of the equation.

5 replies »

  1. That was inserted for the gratuitous purpose of hijacking every issue. Can one imagine their reaction if the story was printed as “a Canadian doctor of Palestinian descent has invented a new inexpensive stethoscope. This is a welcome development as medical innovation by Arabs pales in comparison to what is produced in Israel by Jews.”

  2. Surprised Israel has permitted 3D printing equipment into Gaza since it can be used to made weapons. Perhaps it came via Egypt. Either way we now have to check every shipment into Gaza thoroughly or has Israel’s security apparatus gone soft.

  3. Here the entire list of medical devices and medicines that Israel has EVER restricted from entering Gaza:

    That’s right folks the entire list.

    As for 3-D printers – let’s be real without a barrel and all the other parts a printed gun would last about 3 shots – so why bother to restrict them?