Guardian

Top 7 Guardian anti-Israel errors, lies and deceptions in 2017


Narrowing down an entire year of Guardian anti-Israel reporting to the seven most egregious examples is not an easy task, but, as a public service to our loyal readers, here are some errors, deceptions and outright lies about Israel in 2017 that especially stood out:

1. Guardian op-ed by Diana Buttu claims Palestinians are arrested for ‘criticising Israel’ on Facebook

Diana Buttu’s allegations in the Guardian, including her bizarre claim that Palestinians have been arrested for criticising Israel on Facebook, were context-free and counter-factual – essentially everything you’d expect from a PLO propagandist with such a well-documented record of lying about the Jewish state.

2. Guardian falsely suggests existence of Haredi-only Israeli hospitals

The Guardian’s suggestion that there are haredi-only hospitals is just absurd, as anyone familiar with Israeli hospitals would surely know.  Whilst Bikur Cholim Hospital in Jerusalem likely treats a large number of Haredim (due to its close proximity to Haredi neighborhoods), like all Israeli hospitals, it treats all patients who come through its doors, regardless of religious background. 

3. Guardian falsely claims that Israel ‘banned’ Arab political parties in 2009

An official Guardian editorial claimed that Israel has ‘banned’ Arab political parties. In fact, as we noted in a complaint to editors, though there was, in 2009, a decision by the Israel Central Elections Committee to bar two Israeli Arab parties due to allegations they supported terrorism, the Israeli Supreme Court overturned the ‘ban’ only two weeks later, before it could go into effect.  The Guardian upheld our complaint and issued a correction.

4. Guardian describes Palestinian violence over Temple Mount metal detectors  as a “largely non-violent campaign of civil disobedience”

The advocacy journalism practiced by the Guardian’s Jerusalem correspondent Peter Beaumont seems to demand that the Palestinian cause be framed – regardless of the evidence – as a peaceful and progressive, and so all information that runs counter to this narrative must be whitewashed and obfuscated. 

5. Guardian columnist suggests that Israel’s defenders are akin to climate change deniers.

Guardian columnist Zoe Williams actually compares Israel’s defenders – whom she characterises as defenders of “killing children” – and climate change deniers. This analogy is indicative of a view of the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict, held by many in the media, which sees it as a binary tale of ignorance vs truth, good vs evil.

6. Guardian claims there’s a wall around Haifa

Following communication with UK Media Watch, Guardian editors removed the sentence bizarrely suggesting the existence of a wall surrounding the Israeli city of Haifa, and added an addendum noting the change.

7. Guardian erroneously claims Israel “censored” book by Dorit Rabinyan.

Israelis are free go to bookshops anywhere in the country and purchase the book, Borderlife, by Dorit Rabinyan. The book made it to the Israeli best seller’s list. Israeli students can borrow the book from libraries. Israeli teachers in advanced literature classes across the country are free to assign the book to their students if they choose. Yet, the Guardian somehow claimed that the book was “censored” by Israel.

5 replies »

  1. Congratulations (or should it be condolences) Adam, and colleagues, for another year of dredging through biased reporting in the media.
    Let us hope, I agree it is a forlorn hope, that next year starts to bring about what should be a basic human right. That is access to uncensored, diverse, and trustworthy media so we can make well-informed decisions.

    And let 2018 be the year that anti-Semitism and anti Muslim bigotry are finally consigned to the dustbin they belong in. If that happens, or starts to happen, then it will be a Happy New Year.

    • “the year that anti-Semitism and anti Muslim bigotry are finally consigned to the dustbin they belong in” – ah yes, that idiotic false equivalence again.

Leave a Reply to teddymcnabb Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s