Independent

Indy treats Palestinian street theatre as real life.


The Independent did what it often does when reporting on Israeli removal of illegal, EU funded buildings in Area C (areas of the West Bank under full Israeli control): they illustrated the story with a photo designed to maximize the desired narrative of Palestinian dispossession.

The photo used for the article (Israel demolishes EU-funded Palestinian classrooms in occupied West Bank, Feb. 5) leaves the impression that the demolition of their classroom – funded by the EU in an attempt to create ‘facts on the ground‘ in the contentious E-1 area connecting Ma’ale Adumim with the rest of Jerusalem – forced Palestinians to learn while sitting outside amidst the rubble.

The photo caption used by the Indy also leaves this impression:

Bedouin children attend improvised class in the village of Abu Nuwar, West Bank, after the Israeli army demolished their two-classroom school in the West Bank on Sunday AP

However, the scene is almost certainly staged, and the Palestinians depicted are not in fact forced to learn while sitting on old tyres.  We know that because the full AP photo caption makes this clear:


Indy editors were clearly aware that the children were moved to nearby facilities to continue classes, but decided not to convey this information to readers.  

A more accurate photo showing the same children actually learning in the nearby guesthouse wouldn’t have been as evocative. The site depicted in the photo is not their new classroom, but merely a photo-op.  

The omission of this small detail gets to the heart of the double standards in coverage of the conflict: foreign journalists covering the region are so careful not to amplify or accept at face value the “hasbara” disseminated by the Israeli government or pro-Israel groups, yet seem perfectly willing to report (as real news) such staged protests and other forms of political street theatre.

Related Articles

16 replies »

  1. So nice to see how prosperous the Bedouin community is with children wearing smart school uniform. Just think where Israel was 70 years ago.

    The zoning laws are as much evidence of care as the healthy happy children are

    • Have you ever asked yourself why the EU had to build the classrooms ? Are you aware of the education situation in East Jerusalem where the municipal govt of the “undivided capital of Israel’ doesn’t provide classrooms for thousands of children as required by law ?
      http://www.jpost.com/National-News/ACRI-Just-a-fraction-of-2200-court-mandated-east-Jerusalem-classrooms-have-been-completed-325122
      https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/.premium-jerusalem-has-not-built-2-000-classrooms-for-arab-neighborhoods-1.5433582
      https://www.huffingtonpost.com/ir-amim/failing-grade-by-orly-noy_b_707762.html

          • “The EU should mind its own business. I don’t see it helping poor Jews in Israel. All they do is cause trouble.”

            So the trade in goods between Israel and the EU in 2016 of €*34 Billion just causes trouble and doesn’t help anyone in Israel?
            That students in Israel can participate in the EUs Erasmus+ scheme just causes trouble and doesn’t help anyone in Israel?
            That Israel signed up to the Horizon 2020 Research and Development scheme in 2014 just causes trouble and doesn’t help anyone in Israel? (There has been Research and Development cooperation since 1996 between the EU and Israel)
            That as part of the European Neighbourhood Initiative the EU provides Israel with €2 Million every year for Twinning schemes just causes trouble and doesn’t help anyone in Israel?
            Since the start of this year Israel has begun to participate in the ‘Open Skies’ Agreement, this also just causes trouble and doesn’t help anyone in Israel?

            You’re right gary doesn’t the EU cause a lot of trouble, or are you just ignorant of the facts.

            * 1 euro is worth more than 1 Dollar

        • They reported a Supreme Court decision. Please explain why you believe the City of Jerusalem is allowed to discriminate against children in the undivided capital of Israel? Don’t you think that thus sets a dangerous precedent for when Jews will be a minority in the city? (in about 30 yrs according to the Central Bureau of Statistics, based on current demographic trends).

      • Why on earth couldn’t the EU consult the Israeli authorities about where to build a classroom and cooperate with them, using joint resources, joint knowledge and joint expectations?

        Why does it have to turn into a PR moment and an excuse for hatred and triumph for the regressive left?

  2. Just more disgraceful bigoted dishonesty from The Guardian. Don’t these people have any sense of decency, truthfulness, or self-respect?