Guardian

Dangerous coronavirus advice, and intellectual poverty in Gaza


We’ve posted frequently on the media’s insistence on blaming Israel for the economic and social crisis in Gaza, and their failure to assign responsibility for such woes to Gaza leaders – a pattern on display in a recent Guardian’s article on the first coronavirus patients in the coastal strip.

However, there’s another societal crisis that’s rarely reported on, one which Gaza political and religious leaders are solely responsible for:

This report by MEMRI is a case in point:

This is extremely dangerous coronavirus advice for sure – suggesting that Muslims are somehow less prone to catching COVID-19. But, it’s also part of a larger pattern of intellectual poverty within Gaza, where such counter-factual ideas are often the norm.

Antisemitism, conspiracy theories, and extremism represent the political and spiritual currency of Palestinian society.  As Walter Russell Mead has written, irrational thinking about cause and effect is a sign of profound mental and social failure—and a harbinger of more failures and errors to come. The prevalence of such ideas about how the world works, Mead argues, represents a “tell” that points to important limits on a country’s “potential for political, social and economic progress”.

It’s the widespread acceptance of irrational ideas by their religious and political leaders – and, to a large degree, by the general public – that inspires the prioritization of the destruction of the Jewish state over all other social, political and economic needs, which in turn leads to the terror and aggression necessitating (economically injurious) Egyptian and Israeli blockades.

A Chinese proverb warns that you must watch your thoughts because they become your words, which become your actions, which become your habits, which become your character, which becomes your destiny – an intuitive axiom (falsely attributed to Margaret Thatcher) wildly at odds with a modern ethos which fails to assign agency to any group considered oppressed.

The Palestinian sermon we highlighted is important because history has surely shown that bad ideas almost always result in bad choices and, often, horrible individual and societal consequences – and that we ignore them at our peril.

Related Posts

2 replies »

  1. It’s not just Muslim clerics that talk and behave nonsensically about the Coronavirus. As The Times of Israel reported recently Haredi communities have had high rates of infection, in part because some refused to obey advice about avoiding religious assemblies:

    “Earlier this month, the leader of Israel’s Lithuanian, or non-Hasidic, Haredi community, Rabbi Chaim Kanievsky, initially ordered his hundreds of thousands of followers to defy Health Ministry orders to close schools and seminaries”.

    • And yet the article is not about the Haredi community. And here you are, complaining that it is not.

      This is not the same as your mother complaining about how she wished she had a well adjusted, non-idiot as a son. Unless, of course, she was running a blog.

      But I guess the bottom line, Sencar, is that you do believe the Muslims are chosen to be bypassed in this crisis. How very sweet of you.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.