The media lie of “Jews only” roads in Israel

The following is an English translation of an essay published in the Hebrew edition of Ha’aretz by Yishai Goldflam, director of Presspectiva – a site dedicated to ensuring accuracy and responsibility in the Israeli media.

Do there exist roads in Judea and Samaria that are designated for “Jews only”? Are Christians and Muslims really prohibited from traveling on roads across the Green Line?

This charge, which is often voiced in these parts, including in [Ha’aretz], provokes condemnation of Israel’s alleged racism — and is simply untrue. There appears to be a terminology confusion that produces a factual error that harms legitimate discussion and criticism of Israeli actions. 

Here are the facts: the state did, indeed, impose restrictions on certain roads in Judea and Samaria several years ago and did not allow Palestinians to travel on them, especially after the eruption of the second intifada. But most of the restrictions were already removed in 2009. Today, most West Bank roads are open to the majority of the Palestinian population. And even at the time those roads were restricted for Israeli use, they were never restricted to Israeli Jews alone. The  roads were open to all Israeli citizens – Muslims, Christians, Druze and Circassians. There was never a religious or ethnic-based separation on the roads of Judea and Samaria.

Actually this fact is crystal clear to anyone who has ever been to the area. Only someone who has never traveled in territory over the Green Line could possibly believe the claim that there exist roads for only Jews. Today, one can see license plates of Palestinians from Jenin to Hebron, on bypass roads that were allegedly built for Jews only (for example, the  Qalqilya bypass, the southern Nablus bypass, and the Ramallah bypass roads), as well as on main roads like Route 505 leading to Ariel – a road that was labeled  at least twice in this paper [Ha’aretz] “an apartheid road for Jews only.”

The Associated Press published  a correction in January 2010 stating, “These roads are open to all Israeli citizens, including Arabs,  foreigners and tourists.” Similar corrections were published on  CNN, The Washington Post, and The Boston Globe. But the journalistic responsibility and  professionalism demonstrated by the world’s leading media outlets apparently made no impression on the Israeli media, which even today continues to air this false charge.

Beyond the error itself, the claim of “Jews-only” roads impairs reasonable discussion about Israeli actions. While it is possible to debate and criticize the (real) restrictions imposed on  Palestinians (all Palestinians, not just Muslims) on some West Bank roads during a specific time period, Israel and her supporters are forced to address this bogus claim of ethnic-religious separation on these roads.

Raising this claim, particularly in the Israeli media, grants it validity. Anti-Israel activists, too ignorant and lazy to substantiate their own charges, wave around “facts” they find in Israeli newspapers that supposedly “prove” the racism of the State of Israel and justify their own attacks on her. It’s hardly surprising this mendacious claim has become a major weapon in the attempt to brand Israel an “apartheid state.” Thus, irresponsible journalists and publicists contribute to the distortion of the domestic and international discussion about Israel.

Many media outlets in the world have already acknowledged their mistake and corrected it.  Is the Israeli media capable of meeting the accepted standards of  journalistic integrity?

7 replies »

  1. Why does the Governement of Israel prohibits Palestinians from using roads that are located in their own territory, not in Israel? This is the question.

    • And the answer is that they can’t use them because they have a funny driving habit killing Jews on the way. But you know it already very well and just trolling here a bit.

      • But what are Israeli settlers doing outside Israel, in the occupied Palestinian territory anyway?

    • Well, the custom to kill Jews on these roads must have left a positive impact on you, obviously, as you complain that your compatriot terrorists have no more possibility to do this.

    • No. That’s not the question being discussed here. The question being discussed here is why anti-Israel activists have worked so hard and so effectively to lie outright and claim that these road are ‘for Jews only’, an accusation of racism that is powerful and effective.

      This is a deliberate lie. It is a lie that has been spread to make Israel look racist and monstrous, and it is a lie that is being told to DISTRACT from what you claim to be the real question.

      Arguments about disputed territory, terrorism, and land ownership are hard. “Should only Jews get to drive on the road?” is easy. So the liars who lie about Israel lied about this, so that they could move the debate onto their own terms.

      Moving the debate back, once the lie has been exposed may be all that is left, but it is a little too easy, don’t you think?

      • As a matter of fact, some roads in the West Bank were built by Israel for Jewish settlers and were forbidden to Palestinians living in the West Bank.