Category not assigned

Guardian reviews anti-Israel Guardian play…and approves!


By Richard Millett, London.

Rachel Levy blown up by female suicide bomber in Jerusalem on March 29th 2002.

Rachel Levy blown up by female suicide bomber in Jerusalem on 29th March 2002 (photo: Jewish Chronicle)

The Guardian’s Michael Billington gave My Name Is Rachel Corrie four stars out of five in his review of the anti-Israel play now showing at the Young Vic Theatre in London. Billington’s review doesn’t hide the fact that the play was written by the late Alan Rickman and now Guardian Editor-in-Chief Katherine Viner.

Why oh why did this play need to be revived yet again having been shown in London in 2005 and Edinburgh in 2006? Corrie was killed in Rafah in Gaza in 2003 while standing in front of an Israeli bulldozer that was about the demolish a house that was shielding a Hamas weapon supply tunnel from Egypt into Gaza.

Her death was at the height of the second Intifada when Hamas were using these supply tunnels to blow up Israeli citizens inside Israel using suicide bombers.

Judging by the Billington’s review the play doesn’t mention this crucial narrative. The play merely shows Corrie “was crushed by an Israeli army bulldozer in Gaza” and that Corrie goes to “work in Gaza with the International Solidarity Movement to support Palestinians whose homes were being systematically demolished.”

So there is no mention that at the trial of the driver of the bulldozer he was found innocent by the court because there was no way he could have seen her standing in front of the bulldozer based on how high up he was in his carriage. But the play accuses the driver of murdering Corrie.

Having sent IDF soldier Elor Azaria to prison for killing a Palestinian terrorist and also having done the same to the IDF soldier that killed activist Tom Hurndall the Israeli court would no doubt have sent to prison the driver of the bulldozer if the evidence was there. It just wasn’t.

So I suspect that this destructive, mean, vindictive play that provides nothing of any positivity to the world has been revived because anything anti-Israel provides an instant full house. And, tragically, the timing is highly advantageous what with anti-Semitism on the rise to the extent that the recent Labour Party conference proposed discussion on whether the Holocaust happened.

The director Josh Roche was kicking a ball into an open goal with this revival. He and actress Erin Doherty now have a sold out show at a prestigious London theatre to boast about.

Had the play instead been called My Name is Rachel and included stories of the 19 Israeli Rachels murdered by Hamas (whose tunnels Corrie was trying to shield when she herself was killed) and Fatah during the second Intifada then I doubt the play will have sold many seats.

Incidentally, the Young Vic rejected any such balance itself when it refused a request to have photos of those 19 murdered Israeli Rachels, with descriptions of how they were blown to pieces by Palestinian terrorists, in the foyer during the running of My Name Is Rachel Corrie. Here are their photos and bios

The only people to blame for the death of Rachel Corrie were the International Solidarity Movement and Rachel Corrie herself who was played mercilessly by the ISM. Her death was not caused by Israel. The Corrie family need to accept this and stop allowing the furthering of the hate that is fomented as a result of the lies in this play.

I have read no better piece that sums up the situation Corrie found herself in than Oliver Kamm’s in The Times in 2004 when discussing Channel 4’s programme on Corrie Death of an Idealist:

“Ms Corrie was in fact in the midst of conflicting national claims that must one day be reconciled in a territorial settlement resembling the pre-1967 armistice lines. The cause to which she gave her life inflames that conflict. The ISM does not operate against the terrorist enemies of a two-state outcome. Its “human shields” do not travel on Jerusalem buses in order to protect Israeli civilians from suicide bombers. Its principal activity is knowingly to endanger its young volunteers. As an ISM founder chillingly told The Washington Post: “We’re like a peace army. Generals send young men and women off to operations and some die.””

20 replies »

  1. I saw a video of Corrie once. She was a very screwed up young woman. The biggest role in her death belonged to her, and no one else. All those Israeli/Jewish Rachel’s deaths can, in part, be attributed to Corrie, ISM, HAMAS, and some of their good buddies in England now eulogizing her as some sort of martyr to enlightened thinking, which she plainly was not.
    Viner and Rickman should burn in hell for penning this mischievous and embarrassingly antisemitic-anti-zionist nonsense.

  2. After reading the review in The Guardian I was left wondering if it was a review or the first step in an attempt to beatify then canonize ‘St. Rachel’.
    There are a few things in the review that trouble me, for example;
    “Born in Olympia, Washington – “a place where hippie kids come after touring with jam bands” – she admits to being scared of people, yet driven by a compulsive need to help them. A teenage trip to Russia turns her from a local activist into one with a global awareness. That leads her to go to Israel and work in Gaza with the International Solidarity Movement to support Palestinians whose homes were being systematically demolished.”
    ‘St. Rachel’ admits to being scared of people, yet driven by a compulsive need to help them. I admit I am scared of some people particularly those who carry bombs, guns and knives and shout “Allahu Akbar” before they murder people. But I feel no need or compulsion to help them.
    So ‘St. Rachel’ went to Russia as a local activist, although it does not say a local activist in what. This leads her to go to Israel, why?
    Later the review goes on;
    “……sombrely watchful as she sees Palestinian suffering at first hand. Above all, she conveys the restless intelligence of a young American propelled by the urge to rectify the world’s injustices yet prophetically aware of her own mortality.”
    ‘St. Rachel’ was propelled by the urge to rectify the world’s injustices? Really didn’t she notice any when she was in Russia. If so what did she do about them, if she did not notice any then that raises a whole host of questions.
    And if she was ‘prophetically aware of her own mortality’ WTF was she doing near earth moving heavy plant in a conflict zone?

  3. Corrie’s indoctrination began much earlier. Her parents are as much at fault as ISM. Their decade long crusade to try to shift their guilt to the Israeli bulldozer driver was as wicked as ISM’s ruthless utilization of the naive fools that ISM recruits to its evil purpose.

  4. As Richard knows we are leafletting audiences with the truth before every performance at the Young Vic.

    The Young Vic’s agreement to stage the play was irresponsible. The same applies to Josh Roche, the director, for choosing the play as his entry to the JMK Award and to the (anonymous) judges for awarding him the prize.

    The Young Vic’s creative director, David Lan, refused my request for a ‘debate’ after five of the performances, even after he had justified the staging of the play by saying he wanted to ‘encourage debate’.

  5. I typed “Rachel Corrie” into google and the first page is filled with a whose who of anti-Israel publications, e.g., Electronic Intifada, The Guardian, The Nation, Mother Jones, The Rachel Corrie Foundation. All the usual suspects who buy into the Palestinian narrative almost unquestioningly. For complex historical reasons the I/P (i.e., the long Arab war against the Jews) conflict is a part of a proxy war being waged against capitalism and western civilization by several of them.

  6. One less childish, anti-semitic moron on this Earth. She got what she deserved. You ”play with fire, sometimes you get burned”!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s